All-Time Hall of Fame Inductees
| Honoree | Category | Year Inducted |
| Edmund "Rip" Black '29 | Track, Football | 1986 |
| Ted Curtis, Sr. '23 | Administrator | 1986 |
| John Huard '67 | Football | 1986 |
| Julie Woodcock Shaw '79 | Swimming | 1986 |
| Donald C. Smith '40 | Track | 1986 |
| Charles Akers '61 | Skiing, Cross Country | 1987 |
| Ann Turbyne Andrews '91 | Track | 1987 |
| Thomas "Skip" Chappelle '62 | Basketball | 1987 |
| Richard DeVarney '66 | Football,Baseball | 1987 |
| Francis C. Lindsay '30 | Cross Country, Track | 1987 |
| Harry Richardson '30 | Cross Country, Track | 1987 |
| Sam Sezak '31 | Administrator | 1987 |
| John P. Zollo '49 | Football | 1987 |
| Andre Aubut '82 | Hockey | 1988 |
| S. Thurlow Cooper '57 | Football, Track | 1988 |
| Roger Ellis '60 | Football | 1988 |
| Joseph Ferris '66 | Baseball | 1988 |
| John Gowell '38 | Track, Football | 1988 |
| Chet Jenkins '31G | Coach | 1988 |
| James Smoragiewicz '78 | Swimming | 1988 |
| Stanley Wallace | Trainer | 1988 |
| Jim Butterfield '53 | Baseball, Football | 1989 |
| Gary Conn '81 | Hockey | 1989 |
| Jo-Ann Choiniere '83 | Cross Country | 1989 |
| Carl Ring '25 | Track | 1989 |
| Manch Wheeler '62 | Football | 1989 |
| Alton Bell '37 | Track, Baseball | 1989 |
| Rod Elliot '38 | Football, Skiing | 1989 |
| Marty McHale '11 | Baseball, Football | 1989 |
| Jack Butterfield '53 | Coach | 1989 |
| Helen Lengyel '27 | Administrator | 1989 |
| Don Favor '34 | Track, Football | 1989 |
| Pat French '32 | Track, Football | 1989 |
| Robert Bennett '41 | Track, Football | 1990 |
| Wayne Champeon '61 | Football, Basketball | 1990 |
| Robert Pidacks '51 | Skiing | 1990 |
| Mark Plummer '75 | Golf | 1990 |
| Harold Westerman | Coach, Admin. | 1990 |
| Harold Alfond | Benefactor | 1991 |
| Rufus Harris '83 | Basketball | 1991 |
| Chris Keating '79 | Football | 1991 |
| Carl "Stump" Merrill '66 | Baseball, Football | 1991 |
| Bill Swift '84 | Baseball | 1991 |
| Emily Ellis Throckmorton '85 | Basketball | 1991 |
| Paul Firlotte '56 | Track, Cross Country | 1992 |
| Ed Flaherty '76 | Baseball | 1992 |
| Whitney Leeman Zeiger '84 | Swimming | 1992 |
| Brian McCall | Coach | 1992 |
| Marion Rogers '30 | Coach, Admin. | 1992 |
| Mike Bordick '88 | Baseball | 1993 |
| Dave Cloutier '62 | Football | 1993 |
| Lynn Hearty-Coutts '87 | Softball | 1993 |
| Keith Mahaney '57 | Basketball | 1993 |
| Ed Styrna | Track Coach | 1993 |
| Bob Warner '76 | Basketball | 1993 |
| Gene Benner '70 | Football, Track | 1994 |
| Elizabeth Coffin '88 | Basketball | 1994 |
| Joe Hamlin '38 | Football, Hoop, Baseball | 1994 |
| Jack Leggett '77 | Football, Baseball | 1994 |
| Scott Shulman '77 | Football | 1994 |
| Eric Weinrich '89 | Hockey | 1994 |
| Mike Buck '89 | Football | 1995 |
| Peter Kostacopoulos '57 | Basketball, Football | 1995 |
| Larry Mahaney '51 | Basketball | 1995 |
| George Marsanskis '48 | Track, Football | 1995 |
| Lawrence Schiner '61 | Basketball | 1995 |
| Harold Woodbury '36 | Baseball/Admin. | 1995 |
| Harold Baily '15 | Track | 1996 |
| Rachel Bouchard '91 | Basketball | 1996 |
| Henry Dombkowski '49 | Football | 1996 |
| Walter Reed, Jr. | Golf | 1996 |
| Donald Sturgeon '61 | Basketball | 1996 |
| Mark Sweeney '91 | Baseball | 1996 |
| Amy Corbett Bernatchez '92 | Field Hockey | 1997 |
| Susan Elias Gerken '84 | Track/Cross Country | 1997 |
| Thomas Golden '55 | Football | 1997 |
| Dennis Libbey '73 | Baseball | 1997 |
| Scott Pellerin '92 | Ice Hockey | 1997 |
| Ray Weed '61 | Baseball | 1997 |
| Lorenzo Bouier | Football, Track | 1998 |
| Stuart Haskell '56 | Admin. | 1998 |
| Bethany Heslam Morse '86 | Track | 1998 |
| Jim Montgomery '93 | Ice Hockey | 1998 |
| Bert Roberge '76 | Baseball | 1998 |
| James Stephenson '69 | Basketball | 1998 |
| Rick Bernardo '86 | Baseball | 1999 |
| Frederick Brice | Coach | 1999 |
| Paul Kariya | Ice Hockey | 1999 |
| Bert Pratt '43 | Tennis/Basketball | 1999 |
| Carl Smith '91 | Football | 1999 |
| Mary Lou Winstel '94 | Field Hockey | 1999 |
| Dana Drew '39 | Football, Hoop, Baseball | 2000 |
| Carolyn Bryden Corse '82 | Swimming | 2000 |
| Milton Friend '58 | Riflery | 2000 |
| Al Hackett '53 | Baseball | 2000 |
| John Norris '53 | Basketball | 2000 |
| Dr. John W. Winkin | Baseball (Coach) | 2001 |
| Deb Smith, '94 | Softball | 2001 |
| Peter W. MacPhee, '64 | Track | 2001 |
| Roy G. Warren, '80 | Diving | 2001 |
| Alan A. Switzer Jr. | Swimming (Coach) | 2001 |
| Linwood L. Carville, '53 | Football, Basketball, Administrator | 2001 |
| Shawn Walsh | Hockey (Coach) | 2002 |
| Nathaniel J. Crowley, '42 & `66 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | 2002 |
| Sergio Hebra, Jr., `88 | Football | 2002 |
| Wesley D. Jordan, '63 & `69 | Athletic Trainer | 2002 |
| Ann England Maxim, '84 & `86 | Cross Country, Field Hockey, Track | 2002 |
| Jeffrey D. Spring, `87 | Soccer | 2002 |
| Cindy Blodgett, '98 | Basketball | 2003 |
| Ed Bogdanovich, '54 & '64 | Football, Track | 2003 |
| Terry Horne, '61 | Track | 2003 |
| Chris Imes, '95 | Hockey | 2003 |
| Bill Reynolds, '86 & '92 | Baseball | 2003 |
| Harold Violette, '60 | Football | 2003 |
| Walt Abbott '58, '65 | Football (Coach) | 2004 |
| Janet Anderson '67 | Softball, Volleyball (Coach) | 2004 |
| Baron Hicken '63 | Track | 2004 |
| Patty McCormick Hurlburt '96, '99 | Track | 2004 |
| Claude Pettaway '91 | Football | 2004 |
| Jean-Yves Roy '93 | Hockey | 2004 |
| William Kenyon | Coach | 2005 |
| Jamie Cassidy '00 | Women's Basketball | 2005 |
| Scott King '90 | Hockey | 2005 |
| Dan Kane '88 | Baseball | 2005 |
| Freeman Webb '33 | Track and Field | 2005 |
| Dean Smith | Men's Basketball | 2005 |
| Charlie Broomhall '50 and '55 | Skiing | 2006 |
| Jeff Cross '84 | Men's Basketball | 2006 |
| Archer Grover 1899, 1902 | Men's Track and Field | 2006 |
| Sara Jewett '00 | Softball | 2006 |
| Mike McHugh '88 | Men's Ice Hockey | 2006 |
| Jack Small '56 | Football | 2006 | Ed Barrows '42 | Football | 2007 |
| Andy Bedard '00 | Men's Basketball | 2007 |
| Kevin Buckley '81 | Baseball | 2007 |
| Mike Flynn '97 | Football | 2007 |
| Vanessa McGowan-Ray '00 | Cross Country/track and field | 2007 |
| Garth Snow '92 | Men's Ice Hockey | 2007 |
| George Wood | Equipment Manager | 2007 |
